Trends of Western Studies of the History of the Qur’an; Critical Approach to New Skepticism

Document Type : Research Paper

Author

Assistant Professor, Department of Qur’an and Hadith Sciences, University of Tehran;

Abstract

Until the 1970s in Western Studies the Qur’an was to be a book of reconstructing the history of revelation and the edition of the Qur’an in the first century AH. Wansbrough’s Qur'anic Studies and Crown and Cook’s the Hajarism were considered as a turning point towards a skeptical trend regarding the Qur’an as a historical source of Arabic literature from the middle of the second century. The present paper, based on the historical analysis method, introduces these trends, as well as the issue and their general assumptions, and the most important critiques of the modern skepticism are discussed here. Before the skepticism on the historical authenticity of the Qur’an, four approaches are to be mentioned there: Descriptive, Source-critical, Tradition-critical, and Skeptical approaches in Islamic sources. Then, new revisionists and skeptics’ views, those who believe that the Qur’an was compiled since the middle of the second century, and that narratives of Islamic sources are “salvation history”, are mentioned. Scholars have pointed to inscriptions, Qur’anic codices and recently found coins in criticizing the skeptics’ views. In addition to these sources, two other ways to criticize skeptics are emphasized here as well: “isnād-matn analysis” about narratives, and “the need for a presumption of conspiracy or broad consensus”.

Keywords

References

[1]. آقایی، سیدعلی (1390). «بررسی حدیث‌شناسی خاورشناسان: تبیین و تحلیل یا ترجمه و تدوین». آینه پژوهش، سال بیست و دوم، شمارة یکم، فروردین و اردیبهشت، صص30ـ37.
[2]. ــــــــــــ (1390). «تاریخ‌گذاری احادیث بر مبنای روش تحلیل ترکیبی اِسناد ـ متن: امکانات و محدودیت‌ها». صحیفة مبین، شمارة 50، پاییز و زمستان، صص 101ـ140.
[3]. پارسا، فروغ (1388). حدیث در نگاه خاورشناسان. تهران، دانشگاه الزهرا(س).
[4]. شفیعی، سعید (1397). «رویکردهای گوناگون به حدیث و حدیث‌پژوهی در دوران معاصر». مجلۀ علوم حدیث، سال 23، شمارۀ 2، بهار و تابستان، صص113-140.
[5]. ـــــــــــ (1393). «کهن‌ترین مکتوبات غیر اسلامی دربارۀ ظهور اسلام و قرآن». مجلۀ پژوهش‌های تاریخی ایران و اسلام، شمارة 14، صص60-85.
[6]. موسوی­مقدم، سیدمحمد و مؤدب، سیدرضا (1394). «بررسی نظریۀ شکاکیّت نوین دربارۀ شخصیت و سیرۀ پیامبر(ص)». مجلۀ مطالعات تحول در علوم انسانی، پاییز و زمستان.
[7]. نیلساز، نصرت (1387). «بررسی و نقد دیدگاه ونزبرو دربارۀ تثبیت نهایی متن قرآن». «مقالات و بررسی­ها»، دفتر 88، تابستان، صص151-170.
[8]. Al-Azami, Muhammad Mustafa (2003). The History of the Qur’anic Text from Revelation to Compilation, Leicester, UK Islamic Academy.
[9]. Berg, Herbert (2003). “Competing Paradigms in Islamic Origins: Qur’an 15:89–91 and the Value of Isnads”, in: Herbert Berg (ed.), Method and Theory in the Study of Islamic Origins, Brill, Leiden.
[10]. Burton, John (2010). “Notes towards a Fresh Perspective on the Islamic Sunnah”, in: Mustafa Shah (ed.), The Hadith, v1, Routledge.
[11]. Ibid (1977). The collection of the Qur’an, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
[12]. Cook, Michael (1981). Early Muslim Dogma: A Source-Critical Study, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
[13]. Crone, Patricia and Cook, Michael (1977). Hagarism: The Making of the Islamic World, Cambridge University Press.
[14]. Donner, Fred. M. (1998). Narratives of Islamic Origins: The Beginnings of Islamic Historical Writing, Darwin Press, Princeton, NJ.
[15]. Goldziher, Ignaz (1971). Muslim Studies (Muhammedanische Studien), trans. C.R. Barber and S.M. Stern, London, George Allen & Unwin.
[16]. Gürke, Andreas (2003). “Eschatology, History and the Common Link: A study in methodology”, in: Herbert Berg (ed.), Method and Theory in the study of Islamic Origins, Brill, pp. 179-208.
[17]. Hawting, G. R. (2006). Foreword to The Sectarin Milieu: Content and Composition of Islamic Salvation History (by John Wansbrough), Amherst, New York.
[18]. Ibid (2000). The First Dynasty of Islam, Routledge, London and New York.
[19]. Hoyland, Robert. G (2000). “Earliest Christian Writings On Muhammad: An appraisal”, in: Harald Motzki (ed.), The Biography of Muhammad: The Issue of the Sources, Brill.
[20]. ibid (1997). Seeing Islam As Others Saw It: A Survey and Evaluation of Christian, Jewish and Zoroastrian Writings on Early Islam, The Darwin Press, INC. Princeton, New Jersey, (second printing, 2001).
[21]. Koren, Judith. & Nevo, Yehuda (1991). “Methodological Approaches To Islamic Studies”, Der Islam, Band 68.
[22]. Lester, Toby (2002).”What is the Koran?,” chap. In: Ibn Warraq, What the Koran Really Says: Language, Text, and Commentary,New. York: Prometheus Books.
[23]. Motzki, Harald (2005). “Dating Muslim Traditions: A Survey”, Arabica, 52:2, Leiden: Brill.
[24]. Ibid (2002). The Origins of Islamic Jurisprudence, Translated from German: Marion H. Katz, Brill.
[25]. Ibid (2003). “The Question of the Authenticity of Muslim Traditions Reconsidered: A Review Article”, in: : Herbert Berg, (ed.), Method and Theory in the Study of Islamic Origins, Brill, Leiden.
[26]. Muir, Sir W (1897). The Mohammedan Controversy: Biographies Of Mohammed, Sprenger On Tradition, Indian Liturgy And The Psalter, T. & T. Clark: Edinburgh.
[27]. Neuwirth, Angelika (2003). “Qur’an and History – a Disputed Relationship Some Reflections on Qur’anic History and History”, Journal of Qur’anic Studies, vol. v, no. I, pp. 1-118.
[28]. Nevo, Y. D (1994). “Towards A Prehistory Of Islam”, Jerusalem Studies In Arabic And Islam.
[29]. Nevo, Yehuda D. and Koren (2003). Judith, Crossroads To Islam: The Origins of the Arab Religion and Arab State, Amherst, New York.
[30]. Nöldeke, Theodor (2003). The history of the Qur’an/ by Theodor Nöldeke, Friedrich Schwally, Gotthelf  Bergsträßer, Otto Pretzl ; edited and translated by Wolfgang H. Behn, Brill.
[31]. Ohlig, Karl-Heinz and Puin, Gerd-R (2010). The Hidden Origins of Islam: New Research into Its Early History,Amherst, New York.
[32]. Rippin, Andrew (1985). “Literary Analysis of Quran, tafsir, and sira: the Methodologies of John Wansbrough,” in Richard C. Martin (ed.),Approaches to Islam in Religious Studies, Tucson: University of Arizona Press.
[33]. Saadi, Abdul-Massih (2008). “Nascent Islam in the seventh century Syriac sources”, in: The Quran in its Historical Context, Edited by Gabriel Said Reynolds, Routledge.
[34]. Sadeghi, Behnam/ Goudarzi, Mohsen (2012). “Ṣanʿāʾ 1 and the Origins of the Qur’an, Der Islam, Bd. 87, S. 1–129.
[35]. Saeed, Abdullah (2008)., The Quran: An Introduction, Routledge.
[36]. Schacht, Joseph (1950) , The Origins of Mohammadan Jurisprudence, Oxford, Clarendon Press.
[37]. Schoeler, Gregor (2003). “Foundations for a new biography of Muhammad: The production and evaluation of the corpus of traditions from Urwah b.Al-Zubayr”, in: Herbert Berg, (ed.), Method and Theory in the Study of Islamic Origins ,Brill, Leiden.
[38]. ibid (2011). The Biography of Mohammad: Nature and Authenticity, translated by Uwe VagelPohl, Edited by James  E. Montgomery, Routledge.
[38]. Suermann, Harald (2010). “Early Islam in the Light of Christian and Jewish Sources”, in: The Qurʾān in Context: Historical and Literary Investigations into the Qurʾānic Milieu, Edited by: Angelika Neuwirth, Nicolai Sinai, Michael Marx, Leiden/ Boston.
[40]. Wansbrough, John (2004). Quranic Studies: Sources and Methods of Scriptural Interpretation, Foreword, Translations, and Expanded Notes by Andrew Rippin, Prometheus Books, Amherst, New York.
[41]. Ibid (2006). The Sectarian Milieu: Content and Composition of Islamic Salvation History, Amherst, New York.
[42]. Whelan (1998). ‘Forgotten Witness: Evidence for the Early Codification of the Qur’an’, Journal of the American Oriental Society, vol. 118, no. 1 Jan–Mar.
 
 
Quranic Sciences and Tradition
Volume 52, Issue 1
March 2019
Pages 69-93

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics